YouTube isn’t terribly friendly towards new creators.
Tuesday, April 28, 2026 at 04:46:38
Deja Vu all over again?
Recently, I decided to dip my hooves back into the cesspool that is YouTube. I’ve tried this before and failed, so I wasn’t terribly expectant of results. I’ve have some friends jonesing over it and wanting to see how I worked on things. There’s money in them thar vid-joes! I guess, so why not try it again?
Dealing with any of the big engines is a deal with the devil where you’re eventually going to lose. They hold all the cards, and even if your hand is good, theirs is always better because they can simply draw new cards until they have a better hand. They are the dealer, the player, and the paymaster. I already knew this, and this time was no different. I’m presenting this not as a whine, but as “don’t do the same thing over and over and expect different results.”
To start, making money on YT isn’t the easiest thing in the world. You’re bound by restrictions - content and imagery are big parts of that, but the biggest part is the subscriber base. You don’t start getting payouts until you reach at least 1000 subscribers with so many watch hours on your videos. You do this by allowing advertisers to buy time within your video, so right in the middle of an important part of the work, you get an ad for Fountain Spew, the latest dohickey that would make Ron Popeil go “ewwwww,” or Senator Bedfellow’s re-election campaign. If you’re unlucky, you get ads for things like Yaoi. Ask me how I know…And you see these ads over and over and over. You have some control over how many, but certain ads are forced on videos, including the obnoxious pre-roll ad. But…there’s no guarantees that there will be an advertiser wanting to put an ad on your type of video. Even if you’ve monetized your video and put an ad every 5 minutes (yes, I’ve seen videos like that) there are absolutely no givens that an ad will play. If your viewer has adblock installed, it doesn’t matter - no ad is played and YT knows this, so no money is made. YT knows this from the start because the pre-roll doesn’t play…why they haven’t simply implemented a “Adblock detected, you can’t watch this” system is beyond me. I guess they know that if they do this, it’s going to destroy a good portion of their userbase, but is that userbase doing anything other than watching? That’s a real dilemma and I’m not here to discuss the semantics of it.
Regardless, I established that there was probably no way I was going to make money on this kind of venture without really providing some sort of content that was polished and easily consumable, and I simply don’t have the hardware or time to capture and edit down video. What computing hardware I do posess is dedicated to particular purposes rather than general processing, and that isn’t going to change. There are channels out there doing that kind of work, two of them that I enjoy (Shang066 and radiotvphononut) are very organic and shakeycam in their presentations - but they also have been around long enough to have enjoyed the older YT that was less restrictive.
The fun begins.
All of these things that follow I understand because everything online has been weaponized, but it makes it difficult for those of us that just want to use your services. Doesn’t make it any less painful, however.
The first difficulty I had was actually trying to make an account. Used to be that you just created a gmail account, attached a YouTube account to it, and you were done. I can’t remember if those were separate systems, but now they are, even though they fall under the same general account login. This is probably something we can thank Big G’s hysterical need for social media and the entire “+” mess that they tried for. You can still easily make a gmail account, but now you need to attach other things to it, including a phone number otherwise you can’t verify that you exist, attach another email to it, and then it unceasingly insists that you give it your home address. Now that you have a gmail account, you can go to YouTube and create a channel. You have to create a channel to do anything now on YT, including just comment on a video. Channel has been created, now the fun starts.
Immediately, you’re restricted to 15 minutes or less uploads, and you can’t stream. Ok…what I do is probably more useful as a long-form video or a livestream. Livestreaming makes a little sense, you don’t have any subscribers so there’s no reason to stream, but you need at least 50 to open that up. The other restriction, you need to provide some proof that you’re real. Apparently a phone number that they already have (and was once attached to an Android account) doesn’t count towards this.
Here’s where I ran into problems on my first attempt a few years ago. At the time, the only real way to prove your identity was to photograph your ID and let them fondle it. I reluctantly did so, and was never able to get them to verify the ID and release account restrictions. After about 6 months of posting little videos and not getting anywhere with having restrictions released, I gave up. The stuff I posted gained no subscribers in that time, even though I promoted where I could, and even watch time was very small. I assumed that being uninteresting was probably 95% of the problem, with the other 5% being the logistics of actually getting YT to provide your content to people. I couldn’t gain any traction to even get feedback, and even friends didn’t subscribe because most of them just bookmark the people they want to watch because they don’t like the system.
I deleted this channel and just said “Ok, thank you. I’m sorry, it didn’t work - it’s me, not you.”
This time, I was able to actually verify that I exist and I’m an adult because they allow you to do a short selfie video. I did so, and the next day restrictions on length were lifted. Age restrictions seemed to be lifted as well, I guess there aren’t many 17 year-olds out there with white hair and a beard. Great! Still can’t stream, but let’s build some subscribers.
I posted a couple of videos - one about testing some parts with a new piece of test equipment I have, and another long-form video about working on a device. Nothing fancy, just trying out the platform. It’s not polished, and I sound like a dead pig at the bottom of the ocean, but it is what it is with the hardware I have. Better stuff can come later. Yeah, they go up, no issues, but of course the people that asked me about making videos don’t have accounts so no one subscribes. Well, my bestest friend in the whole world does, but he’s that kind of guy. So I have one. Great, let’s do some more. You’re not going to get an audience without doing something, and I wanted to do something. I figured out what hardware I had would work for this, and a way to easily trim these long-form videos down to a manageable length. Let’s roll!
My ability to use that channel suddenly starts to degrade. I can log in, but actually getting to the dashboard becomes erratic. I start getting lots of error messages until there was nothing but error messages. This seems to be a common thing with YT studio, but no one else I knew that made content was having this issue, even the complainers on that alien site didn’t have anything to say about it. I tried for a few days to make it work but things just … weren’t anymore. I couldn’t edit, view, see, or manage anything. There’s no one to offer help, so I just deleted that and started over with a new channel with a similar name.
Try, try again.
I was able to upload some stuff to this and it seemed to work. However, I had a streaming audio source playing in the background. I like to listen to something while working, and I usually have Music Lake or Space Travel Radio playing. Both of these channels are low-key, low-beat, calm music that goes well with trying to concentrate on something in front of you. I had Music Lake playing, and of course the mic picked up small bits of it.
One of the things you need to remember about anything online is it’s all a weapon. Music, or your use thereof, is a very evil and dirty thing when it comes to video. The music industry got a shock when MP3s came about and suddenly it became easy to share songs. It got another shock when artists found out they could simply bypass the record companies and publish their own music on platforms like YT and other places. To that, the entire industry is now so scared that you might play 30 seconds of a music clip inadvertently in a video and collect 0.00000000000385 cents doing so, that they will blast your channel into oblivion instead of looking at that content and going “Oh, yeah, it’s just a radio playing in the background.” They’ve always been anal about music played in public spaces, but now it’s really real - you can lose an entire body of work because you accidentally played a minute of some crap pap pop poo in your video.
Back to my situation. YT detected 3 instances of something in the background. While it claims to have identified them, it stated that the creator had generally issued a license for this to be used on YT, but this would, to wit, prevent monetization of a video if such a thing were to happen in the future. So, if I want to do this, I can’t even listen to anything. I have to sit there in silence, working on a device. This isn’t going to work for me.
Then we move on to the actual content of the videos. You’re not going to sit there and watch me solder parts and run wire for two hours. It’s not going to happen, and you don’t need to be nice about it, I understand. I wouldn’t watch this and I’m the one doing it. There’s just nothing interesting about the in-between parts, the good bits are the before and after pictures and a discussion of what happened, not watching someone take 30 minutes to figure out why the previous owner of a device did what they did, like they did it, and try to reverse it. You can’t see it up close because it’s deep inside a chassis, and that’s all there is to it. Let’s not even get into the logistics of the things I work with. Pull out the soldering gun to do a big chassis joint? That looks like a firearm and YT isn’t going to like that! The site is so scared of that sort of thing that they will happily de-monetize you if your car’s handbrake happens to look like a firearm in a video - and you’re stuck in support purgatory fighting with LLM responses to your argument.
I take that video down and put up some placeholder posts until I can figure things out.
Yesterday, I get an email from Big G. (no, I’m not saying their name.) “We can’t verify you’re an adult. Please submit more information.” My account is now limited to safe search, and other restrictions for underage individuals has been turned on. I can’t undo this, it’s a permanent thing unless I provide more information to them. This is where the services disconnect comes from. Mail and YT are operated as separate entities under a common umbrella, even though YT really does provide the back-end login services as I understand it. So the video I provided to YT doesn’t count for anything else.
Another selfie video, or preferably a credit card or your ID. They really want your ID, they just won’t say it. Remember the time when this company said don’t use your real name online? Well, too bad, now you need to provide a sample before we’ll allow you to use our service. At this point, the pain in actually getting the account setup, the crap with music clips in the background, the suddenly error’d account, and the desperate wheedling from G about my age is just more than I want to deal with. I can’t even keep the account open without restrictions, so I close it. wereboar-projects is deleted, and I’m not going to recover it. There are only so many hoops this trained boar will jump through before I get tired and go home.
What now?
There are other video platforms, but can you name them? One of them, a site called Rumble, is someplace you may have heard of. Maybe. It’s kind of a odd place. Not what I’d call conspiracy laden, but it certainly attracts a different crowd and it’s known as the site where you go if you can’t use YT. That’s neither bad nor good, and there is plenty of other content there, but they do the same curation and content striking as YT. My videos would be flagged in the same manner. There’s another one, called Brighteon. Bet you didn’t know that one existed, did you? This is where the stranger things go. Again, not bad…just not really someplace that’s going to attract attention, and not where I need to be. They are very hands off on moderation, saying they rely on you to make sure you are providing the proper licensed content. That just tells me that you’re going to get served directly instead of getting content strikes, and I’m not willing to deal with that at all. Again, neither good nor bad, it just has it’s own audience. It’s just not my place.
But in reality, what I’m trying to accomplish isn’t really compatible with video. As I stated, you’re not going to watch someone sitting at a bench just…working. That’s boring. It’s why I don’t talk about the process much, you all know how to put wires in a hole and solder them. I can’t get down in to show what’s going on because that just doesn’t work either. While I haven’t abandoned the idea completely, anything I do in the future will just be short stuff for fun, not an attempt to actually do anything like create a channel.
So…stay tuned, more good junk and projects on the way. Dayton is coming up, Breezeshooters soon after, who knows what we’ll see!
Thank you for your time, and I sincerely appreciate you coming to hang out here on projects.